Christopher nolans new film, interstellar, is a nearfuture tale of astronauts departing a dying earth to travel to saturn, then. What are some scientific inaccuracies in the movie the. However, there is a more sinister player hidden in the. There are no naturally occurring capuchin monkeys in africa. Outbreak 1995 a dangerous airborne virus threatens civilization in this tense thriller. The scene in question however is set in 1967, about years before the decommission of. We have global magnetic field disturbances that only a few scientists notice, what i call the only scientists in the world syndrome. Mar 30, 2002 as both an officer of the us army and a student of medicine and public health, i was appalled by the number of mistakes and inaccuracies in outbreak. Goats and soda we asked epidemiologists and doctors to assess the science in the 2011 movie, in which the character played by. Outbreak is the kind of movie you enjoy even while you observe yourself being manipulated.
A handful of scientists struggle to prevent the destruction of a small town and possibly the entire country in this suspense drama. The great influenza epidemic of 1918 and memoirs about the plague epidemics. Outbreak s plot speculates how far military and civilian agencies might go to contain the spread of a deadly, contagious disease. In planet of the apes 1968 charlton heston faced a future of intelligent apes in the aftermath of a nuclear holocaust but in the 2011 relaunch of the franchise rise of the planet of the apes the fall of humanity follows a global pandemic that kills 1 in 10 humans whilst heightening ape intelligence.
How in the world did they get enough plasma from a single monkey to save thousands of people from a deadly ebolalike. The few that make a miraculous recovery hold the key to saving the rest of humanity. Contagion consultants talk about the movies scientific. Outbreak, i am legend etc it has one major inaccuracy in fact that is both unjust and unnecessary. It started off greati thought it was going to be an excellent movie along the. Sutherland plays a role so familiar that he, himself, can be seen playing the flipside. Dead bodies strewn throughout the streets, cities engulfed in widespread hysteria. In the beginning of the movie, as the camera passes through the various biothreat.
Incorrect science in science fiction films insider. The scene in question however is set in 1967, about years before the decommission of the c123s. In outbreak movies, becoming infected with a disease is nearly an automatic death sentence. Like only a few people notice the superheating of the earths interior or the funny behav. The boxoffice hit contagion, a movie about a lethal airborne virus that kills within days, is still a top dramatic draw going into. The fact checking of the film twister how accurate was it. That is how the authorities in china in general and hong kong in particular are portrayed in the film. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Infectious disease epidemics are widely recognised as a serious global threat. A sudden outbreak of a 100% lethal virus has happened in a small northern california town and doctors from usamrid and the center for disease control rush in to quarantine the town and find the carrier in order to create a cure. It is not only scientific inaccuracies in movies and tv shows, but also historic misportrayals. Sep 16, 2014 in the 1998 movie armageddon, an asteroid the size of texas threatens to collide with earth in 18 days.
The 1995 disaster flick outbreak added viruses to the list of villainous forces of nature that would forever haunt the silver screen. In 2012 neutrinos melt earths core, and other disasters. But what the movie got wrong was how it portrayed the public health communitys access to critical information about the spread of the disease. While the movie contagion is a fictional account of an outbreak of a dangerous infectious disease occurring globally, the reallife stories of cdcs epidemic intelligence service are just as exciting as the one on the screen. Jan 19, 2019 there is a growing collection of viral outbreak films that might serve as a source of information about epidemics for popular culture consumers that warrants critical examination. Contagion was a film released in 2011 about a fictional pandemic of a.
It made scientists look like a bunch of miracleworkers that can cure any. In outbreak, an escaped african monkey unleashes a deadly, ebolastyle virus in. The devastating effect of the recent outbreak of coronavirus covid19 cannot be overstated. Contagion a flawed outbreak of scientific accuracy. Jan, 2014 as a scientist, i too have found myself noting both scientific accuracies and inaccuracies in films and tv shows. The lessons outbreak teaches us about americas ebola scare.
The hoffman character has been recycled out of dozens of other movies. Interwoven into the fabric of the movie are the issues of biosecurity, biological warfare, global transport of pandemic viruses by airtravel and trading in endangered species. Near the beginning of the movie, when the man who smuggled the monkey out of us customs is flying on the airplane, he is approached by a young boy dressed in a cowboy outfit complete with two toy guns. This is helped in no small part by dustin hoffmans excellent and passionate portrayal of. Oct 19, 2011 fictional films of apocalyptic infections. Nobody wants to take anything seriously in a movie like this, in which digital mayhem is the draw. But the consensus among the scientific community is that contagion did get the science right and accurately conveyed the risks that we all face from emerging infectious diseases. From outbreak to contagion, the movies that get pandemics.
Its a fictional virus, but like contagions mev1, it has realworld. As both an officer of the us army and a student of medicine and public health, i was appalled by the number of mistakes and inaccuracies in outbreak. Another minor scientific inaccuracy perpetrated in the name of narrative clarity is when hoffman deduces that the motaba virus has mutated by looking at a. Outbreak isnt a perfect movie, but it is the perfect movie to talk about the way pop culture portrays viruses, specifically ebola, and what that means the worlds new ebola outbreak today. Scenes like this can be found in most films that depict an infectious disease outbreak. Dr druce, head of the virus identification laboratory, compared the virus depicted in contagion to ebola most recently and the sars outbreak in 2003. The current outbreak has hopefully helped people understand the concept of r 0 a little better, says. Oct 12, 2011 but the consensus among the scientific community is that contagion did get the science right and accurately conveyed the risks that we all face from emerging infectious diseases. Having been through the experience of ah5n1, sars and the 2009 pandemic i found the portrayal. Contagion a flawed outbreak of scientific accuracy the bmj. The motaba virus inflicts a swift, horrible death, and only one man can stop it from spreading into a deadly worldwide outbreak in this riveting scientific thriller. Contagion a flawed outbreak of scientific accuracy while in a number of ways the film contagion is superior to other fictional films of apocalyptic infections. Sep 10, 2015 some outbreak films, such as contagion and outbreak, present realistic pathogens that spread fast and kill even faster.
That is the name of a movie about the supposedly true story of a guy that was abducted by aliens. Allinall this is a very enjoyable, thought provoking movie which hits all the right buttons. The new stephen soderbergh thriller contagion presents a terrifying vision of a global pandemic. The 10 most scientifically inaccurate movies of all time. Outbreak the movie eassy essaysoutbreak and the immune system essay the movie outbreak starring dustin hoffman, rene russo, and cuba gooding jr.
As such, this paper considers the motivating factors behind engaging preventive behaviours during a disease outbreak, and the role news and popular media may have in. Are infectious disease outbreak films scientifically. The story is very current, even though this is an older movie. Contagion film is not far from the truth, warns virus.
Viruses and bacteria, human genetics, evolution and mutation, and overall the immune system of the human body. In the 1998 movie armageddon, an asteroid the size of texas threatens to collide with earth in 18 days. The film, released on march 10, 1995, was a boxoffice success and spacey won two awards for his performance. The chopper should not be on civilian freq at an airport far from his. Oct 23, 2016 aside from the memory implants, which is more of a fantastic element, the films main scientific inaccuracy is that gravity on mars seems to be the same as on earth. In the beginning of the movie, as the camera passes through the various biothreat labs, many doors are open to hallways and personnel not wearing masks, and one technician even removes her mask before leaving the lab. Almost every year, hollywood releases yet another blockbuster outbreak film with an entirely formulaic plotline. Motaba, the virus featured in the 1995 film outbreak, is based on ebola. Oct 22, 2011 dr ian lipkin, expert who advised on soderberghs movie, says we must be better prepared for outbreak of deadly disease rachel ellis in new york sat 22 oct 2011 18. Air force inventory at least 10 years before the period in which outbreak is set. On average it takes around 12 years to make the rank of major and after a minimum of 4 years of college, which means that salt would have had to enter the military when he was around 12 or, obviously not possible.
After an african monkey carrying a lethal virus is smuggled into the u. Aside from the memory implants, which is more of a fantastic element, the films main scientific inaccuracy is that gravity on mars seems to be the same as on earth. Dustin hoffman leads a ragtag group of scientists aiming to find a cure for the deadly and fictional motaba virus before the u. A new film about an outbreak of a new infectious disease pleasantly surprises gavin yamey and jimee hwang, because its one that finally gets the science right four things are certain in life. The boxoffice hit contagion, a movie about a lethal airborne virus that kills. Its a cheesy movie filled with all the stereotypes, cliches and scientific inaccuracies you.
Factchecking contagion, the movie about a global virus. There are no naturally occurring pine cones in redwood forests. Other films, such as quarantine and i am legend, introduce a more fantasybased virus that spreads just as fast, but rather than killing its victims, turns them into bloodthirsty monsters. In the beginning of the movie, as the camera passes through the various bio threat labs, many. Many of the historical documentaries and movies show events that probably did not occur. It is impossible to know when exactly the cap begins to break until storms initiate completely.
A reallife outbreak of the ebola virus was occurring in zaire when the film was released. Dr ian lipkin, expert who advised on soderberghs movie, says we must be better prepared for outbreak of deadly disease rachel ellis in new york sat 22 oct 2011 18. What outbreak gets right about the coronavirus crisis the atlantic. Factchecking contagion, the movie about a global virus outbreak.
The nssl said that the cap was breaking and towers were going 30 miles up the dryline. Outbreak involves concepts we have learned such as. I know its obvious the guns are only toys but faa regulations at the time both real world and for the time frame of the movie, which are about the same prohibited. Despite its entertainment value, the film is fantastically inaccurate, astronomer phil. The movie is not a documentary, but there are some important facts behind the fiction. It is quite possible that a childs first exposure to a coral reef is in the movie.
Among other major flaws, he said the suits worn by the crew of the virgil as they walk around outside of their vessel seem much lighter than what astronauts wear when going into space and theres simply no. The 1995 film outbreak offers a narrow vision of heroism during an epidemiological crisis. Christopher nolans new film, interstellar, is a nearfuture tale of astronauts departing a. The film stars dustin hoffman, rene russo, morgan freeman and donald sutherland, and costars cuba gooding jr.
As a scientist, i too have found myself noting both scientific accuracies and inaccuracies in films and tv shows. Nov 12, 2014 what interstellar gets wrong about interstellar travel. Bill mentions to dusty that the sky is going green. Neutrinos due to the large solar flares, there will be neutrinos sent to earth and. What do you think about scientific accuracy in movies. It started off greati thought it was going to be an excellent movie along the lines of richard prestons book the hot zone. Outbreak definition is a sudden or violent increase in activity or currency. What interstellar gets wrong about interstellar travel. I looked the title up, and noticed something that is bad. In fact, marss mass is roughly 10 percent of earths, and gravity is about 37 percent of what we experience on our planet. Oct 19, 2011 a new film about an outbreak of a new infectious disease pleasantly surprises gavin yamey and jimee hwang, because its one that finally gets the science right four things are certain in life. Feb 16, 2020 the very fact that the movie script mentions the r 0 factor is a plus, say the specialists. Top 5 science done wrong moments in movies science. The movie outbreak starring dustin hoffman, rene russo, and cuba gooding jr.
The fairchild c123 provider aircraft shown dropping the bomb in the film was withdrawn as obsolete from the u. In reality, even the deadliest diseases dont have mortality rates as high as those in the movies. The character salt is a major, and was only in his mid20s or so. Outbreak is a 1995 american medical disaster film directed by wolfgang petersen and based on richard prestons nonfiction book the hot zone. Are infectious disease outbreak films scientifically accurate. Naacp image award bester nebendarsteller cuba gooding jr. The screening, held at the doherty institutes, was followed by a panel discussion about the scientific accuracy and similar outbreaks that have occurred in reality. Disease is spreading, and humans, for perhaps the first time, begin to realize they were just placed on the endangered species list. Physicist john ortberg rewatched the core for the toast and then proceeded to take apart several scientific inaccuracies in the film.
One film whose scientific depictions recently caught my eye is the 2011 medical thriller. Unfortunately, the films main concern is action and not scientific accuracy. The accuracy of 10 disaster flicks science sometimes gets twisted for the sake of a welltold story. Mar 27, 2020 the devastating effect of the recent outbreak of coronavirus covid19 cannot be overstated. The wired conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our livesfrom culture to business, science to design. What are some scientific inaccuracies in the movie the core.
The lessons outbreak teaches us about americas ebola. Movies and scientific accuracy microbiology society. Overall, outbreak is an excellent movie, combining a very believable scenario, presented with reasonable scientific accuracy, with copious helpings of action and suspense all in the one movie. Those final scenes underscore contagions dedication to scientific accuracy. In outbreak, an escaped african monkey unleashes a deadly, ebolastyle virus in a northern. In fact, i ran a movie club, this film is rated phd, where graduate students discussed and debated portrayals of science by hollywood. A fire in the sky is the title of a movie from 1978 about a comet that hits phoenix. The need to educate the public regarding health and safety during an epidemic is particularly apparent when considering that behavioural changes can have a. In the mid1960s, a deadly virus is discovered in zaire.
1201 180 816 447 1334 1049 1149 358 1251 626 1021 267 523 319 109 39 16 675 1507 823 1071 226 794 359 43 100 1364 795 702 352 340 638 841 626 501 818 936